Altos Research Real Estate Insights - California real estate

Home Prices in Oakland vs. Berkeley

Mike Simonsen — Sat, 14 Jun 2008 13:18:02 -0700

Checking out Andy Kaufman's blog this morning, I couldn't help but noticing the contrasting AltosCharts he's showing for Oakland and Berkeley California.

Oakland of course is the bigger city, but these next-door-neighbors share some parts that are virtually indistinguishable from each other. There are some spectacular parts of Oakland and sketchy parts of Berkeley and vise versa. But look at the home price trends over the last year.

Real estate prices in Oakland and Berkeley, California as of mid-June 2008. Data for single family homes.

Likewise look at the trends in inventory levels for the same to cities.

Real estate inventory levels of homes for sale in Oakland and Berkeley, California. Data for single family homes through mid-June 2008

You couldn't have a clearer picture of the real estate pricing phenomenon we're seeing all over the country. It works like this:

Demand is off everywhere and everyone knows it.
So if you're a home buyer in the East Bay with good cash and good credit, you get your pick. In this case, Berkeley has generally better schools, more cachet, etc., so the buyers go there first.
There's enough demand to keep the market afloat.
If you don't have good cash and good credit, you get nothing. There is literally no spillover demand for Oakland.
A few years ago, a home buyer might look to the nicer neighborhoods in Oakland for additional inventory or a lesser school-premium price. Not the case any more.

Actually, I'm sure we could dig through the zip code level data in Oakland and illustrate a similar phenomenon within the cities themselves. But this particular story jumped out at me this morning, so that's what gets covered.

Altos Links: Oakland real estate data, Berkeley Real Estate Data

Check out this chart of inventory in San Jose

Mike Simonsen — Sun, 08 Jun 2008 13:42:51 -0700

We're have an internal game here at Altos - Guess the San Jose Market Bottom. It's quite clear that you can't predict the market bottom by looking at the price chart alone, but what else should you look at? Inventory provides a clue. Check this out:

Single family homes for sale in San Jose. Data from January 2005 through June 2008. Note that in 2007, the typical summer-seasonal inventory plateau burst.

The seasonal cycles are pretty clear, no? Usually there's a summer plateau in the number of homes for sale, then properties drop off through the winter.

The question is, Is that the first inkling of a summer plateau this year?

If inventory levels flatten out this sumer then maybe, just maybe, the worst of the carnage would be over. That inventory could work its way out over the next couple years. What do you think? Is the recession going to make this chart jump even higher this fall?

Here's where you can keep an eye on the live San Jose real estate data.

Will Prices Continue to Fall In Milpitas?

Mike Simonsen — Wed, 28 May 2008 04:48:00 -0700

Here's a funny Meebo-IM chat I had with a home buyer yesterday. This guy is looking for a negotiating angle with home sellers. Smart!

[15:37] meeboguest: hi

[15:37] mikesimonsen: hi

[15:38] meeboguest: will prices in Milpitas Area continue to fall?

[15:38] mikesimonsen:

[15:39] meeboguest: seriously....how do I negotiate with seller to factor another 10% reduction in price?

[15:40] mikesimonsen: well, you can bring our Milpitas report with you and use it to illustrate not only prices, but demand levels and days on market trends

[15:41] mikesimonsen: you can say, "Look at this, you've got easily another few months before this thing moves and I'm willing to buy now!"

[15:41] mikesimonsen: In the reports it even breaks up the data by price range in that zip code

[15:42] mikesimonsen: so you can say, "The market is even worse for sellers of homes like this. So you're lucky you found me!"

[15:42] meeboguest: thanks...I am even luckier if that report is free

[15:43] mikesimonsen: for $19 you're getting a bargain!

[15:43] mikesimonsen: I'll expect a thank-you bottle of wine when you get your price

15:43] meeboguest: how do i get the report?

[15:44] mikesimonsen: go to this page, register, and buy the basic report: http://www.altosresearh.com/research/CA/MILPITAS

[15:44] meeboguest: thanx

[15:45] mikesimonsen: you bet! good luck!

What do you think the chances are that the Seller's Agent is prepared with market data to counter-negotiate? My guess is that they'll get blindsided by this aggressive buyer's approach. Maybe, just maybe, we can motivate the seller's agent to prepare better in the future...

Charts around the Bay Area for April 14

Mike Simonsen — Mon, 14 Apr 2008 15:12:38 -0700

Spent much of the day looking up data for press requests. Everybody wants to know if we're at a bottom. Thought I'd drop some in here. Not a lot of time to write today, so here are some comparison charts for homes around the Bay Area. San Francisco, Burlingame, Walnut Creek, and San Jose. All Data as of April 11 2008.

Median Price Trends for homes in San Francisco, Burlingame, San Jose, and Walnut Creek.

Days on Market for the same cities. Note the seasonal decline still leaves us higher than last year at this time.

Our Market Action Index for the same cities. This is a composite of market demand statistics rolled into one number. Under 30 implies demand weakness, or "buyer opportunity." Under 20 is frigid. Given the tight scale on this chart, conditions are not worsening considerably in the last few months.

Chart of the Day: Price Per Square Foot San Francisco Condos

Mike Simonsen — Mon, 31 Mar 2008 07:48:39 -0700

A couple of charts to chew on this morning.

How's the condo market in San Francisco? Are all those new developments flooding the market yet? Let's look at pricing and value trends for Condos in the city.

Median Price Per Square Foot for condominiums and TICs in San Francisco. Data as of March 30 2008.

Looks like pricing trends are holding nicely in the past year. Why is that? A quick hypothesis is that despite the fact that there are tons of new developments coming on line, the existing inventory of condos is actually very low relative to the population and immigration in San Francisco.

SocketSite shows some year over year inventory charts for real estate in San Francisco today. Here's how the inventory breaks out between single family and condominiums.

Inventory of homes for sale in San Francisco as of March 30 2008. Includes pendings.

Altos links: San Francisco real estate reports

Real Estate Data: Austin Edition

Mike Simonsen — Tue, 19 Feb 2008 14:40:39 -0800

The New York Times last week carried a story on the tale of two housing markets.

AUSTIN, Tex. â The real estate market these days is a tale of two Americas, and one of them is not doing too badly.

In the America of big-city housing markets, especially on the coasts and in the struggling industrial Midwest, the huge run-up in values in recent years has given way to big drops in prices and sales volume. Millions of people owe more than their houses are worth.

But in the other America, specifically in cities like Austin; Grand Forks, N.D.; Yakima, Wash.; and Salem, Ore., the available evidence suggests the real estate market is holding up. Prices there never boomed as crazily as they did in the big cities, and now, even though volume is down almost everywhere, prices in many of these towns are firm or rising.

We'll leave aside the fact falling prices in the struggling industrial towns and the falling prices on the coast are barely related to each other and focus instead on the last statement.

Are home prices in Austin, Texas indeed holding up? Let's look:

Comparing home price trends in Austin Texas, Phoenix Arizona, and San Diego CA

From our perspective, Austin is indeed holding up better than some of the most bubbly markets, like Phoenix and San Diego.

Keep in mind though that in every market, the answer is: it depends. It depends on your price point, it depends on your neighborhood. In fact if we dive into Austin a little deeper, we find where that even though the prices haven't adjusted deeply, we can see where market demand is indeed cooling.

Days on Market for homes in Austin Texas. Data as of February 15 2008. Each line is a price quartile. First Quartile are the most expense 25% of homes on the market.

Days on market is climbing steadily across all price points. Despite a seasonal improvement in market time, The high end of Austin is on the market for a pretty long time right now. Buyers are in no hurry.

Furthermore, in Austin, when you look at the price quartiles, you can see the top of the market is squeezing but the bottom remains reasonably solid. This often implies, as the Times suggests, that the underlying economy is strong, immigration is positive, and people aren't so worried about their jobs. Here's the chart of home prices in Austin, by quartile. Note the slight squeeze at the top end of the market.

Real Estate Price trends in Austin Texas as of February 15 2008

So I'll conclude with a cautious agreement with the Times. Yes indeed there are markets so far escaping major carnage. Many of these markets didn't have the incredible upside in the past few years, so that stands to reason. Finally though, nearly all markets are showing signs of weakness. The key worry for all these markets is that they're following the economy, not leading it. If a recession evolves into full bloom, I don't see how anyone is spared.

Links:

Austin Real Estate Report

San Diego Real Estate Report

Phoenix Real Estate Report

February 2008 National Housing Market Report

Mike Simonsen — Tue, 12 Feb 2008 12:41:34 -0800

Last week we published the February editition of our National Housing Market report [PDF download]. I was traveling and forgot to add it to the blog, so here it is. We've expanded the coverage this month and added a few more cities ebyond the initial 20 covered by the Case Shiller Index. We'll add a few more important cities in the upcoming versions of the reports too.

Here are the highlights from this month's report.

Listing prices declined in 19 of 22 markets during January. Prices only increased in the New York metro area during January and were flat in Dallas and Phoenix.
The largest monthly decline of 3.6% occurred in San Francisco. Over the three month period, listing prices in San Francisco have fallen by 6.1% from $708,551 to $665,100. The other California markets of Los Angeles and San Diego logged declines of more than 2% for the month of January.
Property inventories declined in most markets except in the Northwestern markets of Seattle and Portland. Inventories tightened sharply in the Midwestern markets of Cleveland and Detroit with decreases of 10.4% and 5.4% respectively during January. Seasonal declines in listing inventories are typical during the winter months.
Markets with the longest time-on-market are Miami and Minneapolis at an average of 144 days-on-market. Miamiâs days-on-market only increased slightly from the previous monthâs 143 days while Minneapolis jumped over 5% from 136 to 144 days. Sixteen of 22 markets had an average days-on-market of over 100.
Denver led all markets with the fastest rate of inventory turnover at 61 days, followed closely by Dallas and San Diego at 80 days. The sharp decrease in Denverâs days-on-market indicator â almost 39% during the past three months â coupled with an inventory reduction of over 11% during the same period, should be a positive for listing prices in the coming spring selling season.

Measuring the Decline in the Sacramento Housing Market

Mike Simonsen — Mon, 04 Feb 2008 11:24:13 -0800

Jonathan Miller published the November Radar Logic RPX housing market report over the weekend. It's easy to spot that Sacramento is leading the nation down.

[aside: Radar Logic is cool. They measure Price Per Square Foot and try to do it across all properties, condos and single family homes, new and existing construction. No small task. The price per square foot approach is intended to measure value of the property regardless of the size of the property itself. In the real estate derivatives trading business, Radar is getting all the mindshare. Case Shiller is falling behind. more here.]

In the report just published for November, Sacramento saw a price-per-square-foot decline of 18%. Zowie. For those of you unfamiliar with California's central valley, this is an area dominated by lots of new construction, in huge projects, partly as Bay Area super-exurb. So the underlying economy in the Central Valley isn't nearly as dynamic as San Francisco, San Jose, or Los Angeles. Also much less dominated by the high-end, Sacramento is feeling the subprime fallout harder than most.

So Radar Logic is publishing for November. What are the real-time stats saying? Sacramento is not seeing any relief yet. Here's our price per square foot for Sacramento through February 1 2008.

Price Per Square Foot for single family homes in Sacramento, CA through Feb 1 2008. Notice the price is slightly higher than the Radar Logic number. That's because we track Condominiums separately and this is for the city of Sacramento specifically. The important factor is the direction.

Sacramento Housing Market Data Links:

Our free Sacramento Real Estate Research page

Here's a solid Sacramento Area Blog for more local flavor.

Getting Some Attention!

Mike Simonsen — Fri, 04 Jan 2008 09:54:09 -0800

We've had some really nice attention in the press and blogosphere the past week or so. Here's a quick summary so you can see what people are saying about Altos.

O'Reilly Radar: Tim O'Reilly highlights our real-time data products for Wall Street and the housing derivatives markets. I'll be presenting on this topic at the O'Reilly-sponsored Money:Tech conference in New York February 6-8.

In SFGate.com / San Francisco Chronicle Carol Llyod finds her friends in the market for a home in San Francisco - everyone is surprised how hot the market is. I love this kind of analysis. The data reveal so much more than the headlines can capture. Carol - have your friends email me and I'll set them up with the neighborhood level and insights that we do in our detail reporting.

Dustin thinks we're going to get acquired. And Robbie gives us a nice plug on Rain City Guide.

The bloggers at Redfin have been especially prolific lately. I like the approach Redfin uses for their blogging work. They've got a team of bloggers, each with an intelligent voice, tackling the local real estate markets they're in. None of it is too controversial, but it's solid content, targeted well for their customers.

Altos Links:

National Data for the Housing Derivatives and Case Shiller markets

San Francisco housing market

San Jose Housing Market starts 2008 with twice the inventory of 2007

Mike Simonsen — Wed, 02 Jan 2008 08:36:44 -0800

Some posts just write themselves.

Inventory of homes on the market in San Jose California as of January 2008

Single Family Home Prices in San Jose California as of January 1, 2008

Can't. Help. It. Must. Write. More.

Ugly? You betcha. Do these tell the whole story? Not a chance. In Silicon Valley, San Jose is the dominant market, of course. San Jose is a diverse community, with lots of sub-prime and other crazy loans in the past few years. But also some really great neighborhoods with prosperous, fully employed folks. Lots of big, but not-risky loans too. Here's how the market in a desirable part of town, Willow Glen, is holding up. I've done the price chart in Quartiles so you can see the trends at each price point in the market.

Homes in the Willow Glen neighborhood in San Jose, CA zip 95125. Prices holding up much better than the broader market in San Jose.

Available homes in Willow Glen neighborhood of San Jose CA as of January 1 2008. Inventory is up, but much less than the rest of the city.

Link: San Jose Housing Market.

South Beach vs. North Beach San Francisco

Mike Simonsen — Tue, 20 Nov 2007 15:04:55 -0800

Our friend Alex at theFrontSteps is hosting his occasional Battle Royale this week. He's comparing the North Beach vs. South Beach neighborhoods in San Francisco. Your job is to pick the winner. Where would you rather live, and why? As Alex points out, this debate really boils down to whether you're old school or new skool San Francisco.

I've never been a North Beach guy. Maybe it's the Italian food thing. On the other hand, when I moved to the city almost 10 years ago, there was essentially no such thing as a "neighborhood" in South Beach. So I lived in Potrero, which shares the 94107 zip code with South Beach. As I zip through the ball park area these days, I'm blown away by the changes. It's all so new that it feels a little soul-less. That's such a surprise in San Francisco. I have a feeling though, maybe if I were migrating today, I'd wind up there. I'm clearly not old-school San Francisco.

Anyway, check out the Battle and let Alex know your thoughts.

Bonus: Altos client Mark Choey blogs all about the new development condos in the South Beach area.

On Wildfires, Black Swans, and Home Prices.

Mike Simonsen — Tue, 23 Oct 2007 10:38:12 -0700

A paper in the Journal of Emergency Management came across my desk today. Measuring the Efficacy of a Wildfire Education Program in Colorado Springs

Timely, considering the state of Southern California right now and of Tahoe earlier this summer.

The program sounds like a fascinating way to increase awareness of the fire risk (awareness being the key factor in reducing the controllable variables). Preparation for disasters like this is of course subject to the Black Swan effect:

...most people are uncomfortable making risk estimates of uncertain events such as wild fires... They may think, "There has never been a wildfire where I live, so it is very unlikely that there will be one in the future."

So what can public policy do to motivate people to better manage their exposure? In Colorado Springs, they evaluated every parcel, 35,000 of them, and gave each a rating. Now the city can tell me I have a very-high-risk property and get me thinking about trimming the pine boughs back from my cedar-shingle roof. Then they publish that information. When I go to buy a home in the area, I can factor that into my purchase. That's positive.

But is it effective? And how do we measure changes in risk perceptions? The authors of the paper took a novel approach.

Rather than simply measuring changes in risk perceptions, we examine the effect of the program on the housing market. This provides a more complete picture of how the CSFD approach to education affects homeowner attitudes toward wildfire risk.

A market-based approach. Nice. Incent homeowners to fix the easy stuff that makes up most of the wildfire risk. Very cool.

And the results?

Perhaps the most striking result is that pre-assessment home prices and wildfire risk were positively correlated. In other words, houses with higher wildfire risk also had higher sales prices. The reason for this is [otherwise desirable features also increase fire risk]...building on a ridge may increase the wildfire risk, it also provides better views.

In contrast, post-assessment there is no such correlation. Post-assessment wood roofs and wood siding now have a negative impact on price. As a result, people are migrating to safer building materials.

Good stuff. Too bad it's a lesson a bit too late for the disasters this week. We'll keep an eye on the data to see if we can discern any immediate impact on home prices in San Diego from the fires. Will report back soon.

Damned Lies and Median Home Prices

Mike Simonsen — Mon, 24 Sep 2007 07:39:17 -0700

The bubble is bursting all around us and the National Association of Realtors comes out with a report that San Francisco Bay Area median home prices increased by 13% in the second quarter. Nooooo, can it be? If you can't trust NAR, who can you trust?

Stephen Bedikian of RealIQ has a nice piece today over at Inman News sorting through the confusion. He cites some Altos numbers to help make sense of the turmoil. Stephen concludes:

So what actually happened? Sales transactions increased with a greater proportion on the high end versus the previous quarter. There appears to have been little actual appreciation as evidenced by the Case Shiller and OFHEO numbers, while inventory increased and prices of many listed properties were reduced. So next time you read that median house prices have increased in your area, don't celebrate prematurely. Conduct more research before you reach a conclusion about market conditions in your area.

In addition to Stephen's suggestion of diversifying your stats, I'll add that if you're not looking local, you're not looking anywhere. The Bay Area market? Are you kidding? This spring, you could indeed watch a few key markets, like Palo Alto and up the Peninsula stay strong. But look even a few miles inland, say Antioch, and the carnage was everywhere.

To be fair to NAR, we reported the same trends for some of those parts of the Bay Area in February, March, and April. We also noted that by May, the Spring price growth had already begun to recede. (Notably correlated, by the way, with the widening spreads on jumbo mortgages that started at that time. Surprise! The high-end starts to fade when fat mortgages get more expensive.) So here we are five months later and NAR is telling you that San Francisco had a strong spring. Thanks guys.

[ps. sorry about the long hiatus from the blogosphere. Hope you've been enjoying Scott's posts on real estate e-marketing tactics. Our plan is to intersperse both topics together. Thanks to Stephen for getting me off my ass and posting. I like his work, we'll have to do more together in the future.]

Yahoo! Article - "Home Sales Hit Slump"

Scott Sambucci — Mon, 27 Aug 2007 08:12:48 -0700

http://biz.yahoo.com/ap/070827/economy.html?.v=13

Is the market doing badly?Â Well, I guess the correct answer is:

It depends. . .

Here's the Altos 90-day rolling average for Median Home Prices by Price QUARTILE for various cities across the US since the Spring.

Miami, FL

Phoenix, AZ:

Scottsdale, AZ

Portland, OR

Austin, TX

Â
Palo Alto, CA

Washington DC:

Super Cool Bay Area Real Estate Market Mashup

Mike Simonsen — Tue, 31 Jul 2007 08:50:56 -0700

Client, friend, and indefatigable blogger Kevin Boer has a really slick map mashup of our AltosCharts housing price charts for the Bay Area, using our price quartile data. Kevin uses Zeesource and the result is prettier than our own map mashup (though ours covers all our markets and has a zoom-in-to-the-zip-codes feature.)

AltosCharts map mashup by Kevin Boer at 3OceansRealEstate.com

Our AltosCharts service is up for the Most Innovative Technology award at the Inman Connect conference this week. It's partners like Kevin that really illustrate the power of using market analytics to inform. We're proud to count him as a client. I'm not sure how the winners are selected for these awards, but maybe fans of Kevin's work will stuff the ballot box for us.

And while I'm patting myself on the back, here are a couple of other Altos clients that use AltosCharts really well to bring value to their readers, and boost their own marketing return:

The Harper Team in the East Bay

Pat Kapowich in Sunnyvale

SeattleHome.com

(BTW - I don't mean to exclude any other clients and your sites. There are too many to mention. Feel free to add your site to the comments of this blog if you want to show off your AltosCharts work. I'll work up a post highlighting other sites soon.)